The Senate Judiciary Committee on Thursday passed a strike-and-insert amendment for Committee Substitute for HB4311.
Donald Kersey, General Counsel for the Secretary of State, told the Committee it was a Secretary of State’s proposal. The bill deals with several election-related activities that are currently misdemeanors and makes them felonies if committed knowingly and willfully.
Illegal activities include knowingly and willfully:
· voting more than once in any election, whether held in West Virginia or between West Virginia and another state;
· procuring or attempting to procure the acceptance of illegal votes or the rejection of legal votes;
· altering ballots or deceiving voters with intent to deceive;
· altering the ballot of a voter by marking out the name of any person for whom such voter desires to vote; or, with like intent, writes the name of any person on such ballot other than those directed by the voter; or with like intent, makes any alteration thereof, whether such ballot be voted or not]
· defrauds any voter at any election, by deceiving and causing him to vote for a different person for any office than he intended or desired to vote.
The penalty for committing any election felonies shall be imprisonment for not less than one year but not more than 10 years or fined not more than $10,000, or both, in the discretion of the court.
Senator Richard Lindsay of Kanawha County asked several questions about hypothetical situations where someone voted twice by mistake. Asked whether other states have this level of penalty, Mr. Kersey said he did not know.
Asked why the Secretary of State wanted the offenses to be felonies, Kersey responded, “We want people to know we take this seriously. We want prosecutors to take this seriously.”
Senator Mike Romano of Harrison County spoke against the bill, noting the effect it’s going to have for getting poll workers and ballot commissioners. He described the language as vague, especially about “procuring or attempting to procure” the acceptance of illegal votes or the rejection of legal votes.
Senator Ryan Weld of Brooke County said, “I would like to, in hopes of ending this long, national nightmare, change the word procure to causes.” His amendment passed.
Senator Weld spoke in favor of passage of the bill, pointing out prosecutorial discretion and how few would pursue the cases because of the amount of time it takes to prosecute a felony.
“I can’t imagine any prosecutor having time to chase down someone who voted twice,” Weld said. |